Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Final huck essay

Jack Coyston

Ms. Servais

English 1A

 

Huckleberry Finn: Racist or Satire?

            Fare warning there may be some offensive language used in this essay and my intent was not to offend anyone but to analyse the book Huckleberry Finn. I hope not to offend anyone with what is printed below.

 

            The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain has been called the greatest American novel ever written. Many people say that this book lead the way for other great authors and inspired many to become writers. However, there are also many critics who accuse the book of being racist ignorant garbage that should never see the light of day. It is my belief that Mark Twain did intend on writing a satire about how slavery was wrong and certain people’s ignorant view of African Americans were wrong, but I don’t know if he achieved his goal. Personally I was offended countless times while reading this book and although I can tell that Twain was trying to write a satire, I don’t think he succeeded. In order for something to be considered “satire” you have to be able to find humor in it, this was not the case in Huckleberry Finn; Twain’s portrayal of Jim is so over the top and offensive that it is not funny in anyway.

            Throughout the whole novel Jim is portrayed as a dumb, ignorant slave, who could never amount to anything. Twain portrays Jim in such a way that everything he does makes him seem simple and almost child like.  We are first introduced to Jim in the second chapter when Huck and Tom are sneaking out and Huck says, “We scrouched down and laid still. Miss Watson’s big nigger, named Jim, was setting in the kitchen door” (Twain 35). This description is so short, yet there is so much behind it. We as the reader are made to feel like Jim can be summed up in one word, “nigger.” It seems like there is nothing more about Jim that we need to know, other than that he’s Ms. Watson’s slave and he’s black. By describing Jim like this he falls into a stereotype that most people believed in at the time. That stereotype was, and sadly still is to some people today, that African American people should be slaves because they were dumber and weaker than white people and being a slave was all they were good for. Lester out it best when he wrote,

Jim does not exist with integrity of his own. He is a childlike person who, in attitude and character, is more like one of the boys in Tom Sawyer’s gang than a grown man with a wife and children, an important fact we do not learn until much later. But to Twain, Slavery was not an emotional reality to be explored extensively or with love. (365)

Just like Lester, I feel that Twain doesn’t really care about slavery, and is only characterizing Jim the way he does because he feels that’s how most readers will accept him, which at the time they did because he was what they considered your average slave. However, this is not how most people view African Americans today and so now it comes across as extremely racist. Twain continues the stereotype of “Niger Jim” throughout the book by how he makes him talk, the first thing that Jim says is, “Who dah?” (Twain 35). This is not how a respectable, intelligent member of society would talk, it is almost broken English. “Say-who is you? Whar is you? Dog my cats ef I didn’ hear sumf’n. Well I knows what I’s gwyne to do. I’s gwyne to set down here and listen tell I hears it again” (Twain 35). Jim talks like this throughout the whole book and it just makes him seem as if he’s unintelligent and almost child like.

            In this book Jim is not only portrayed as ignorant and dumb by how he talks, but also by the things that he does. The book is set when slavery was still present in the south and as a African American slave in America at this time one can only assume that Jim would be aware that if he travelled to a northern state he would be free and if he travelled to a southern one he would most likely be captured and made a slave again, yet he and Huck travel South even though it was very well known that African Americans were free in the north. Lester explains that,

The novel plays with black reality from the moment Jim runs away and does not immediately seek his freedom. It defies logic that Jim did not know Illinois was a free state. Yet Twain wants us not only to believe he didn’t, but also accept as credible that a runaway slave would drift south down the Mississippi River, the only route to freedom he knew being at Cairo, Illinois, where the Ohio River meets the Mississippi. If Jim knew that the Ohio met the Mississippi at Cairo, how could he not have known of the closer proximity of freedom to the east in Illinois or north Iowa? (366)

I agree with Lester, Twain makes it extremely hard to believe that anyone in Jim’s situation would make a mistake as big as heading further south and never trying to correct the mistake, and if we can’t believe that Jim is like a real person then we can’t believe any of the book is real. So Twains excessive use of the N-word throughout the book has no reference to the period that it is set in, because the story isn’t suppose to be true. So in essence by making Jim such an unbelievable character Twain loses all credibility and seems like he only uses the N-word how he does because that’s how he actually feels.

            Another problem that I had with this book was the excessive use of the N-word; I personally found it extremely offensive. Many people who support the book say that Twain used the N-word so excessively to get his point across. They argue that he wanted to prove that the use of the N-word is wrong and that it shouldn’t be used so much on a daily basis. This argument is validated by the fact that Twain was born in 1835 and died in 1910. He lived during a period where slavery was very commonplace and he heard the N-word on a daily basis even after slavery was abolished. Kaplan says, “This novel, a savage indictment of a society that accepted slavery as a way of life, nevertheless has come under attack in our time for its alleged ‘racism’” (278). I agree with Kaplan, to Twain the N-word was just part of every day life and I think he wanted to change that by showing how ridiculous the use of that word was. However, I also agree with people who dislike this book because of it’s racist tone, because I think that as times have changed people have begun to realize how offensive it really is to use that word and so it is no longer used so commonly in our society. So in a sense the book is outdated and by forcing students to read it many teachers run the risk of offending a lot of people. Although I agree that Twain used the N-word so excessively to get his point across I also believe that it has made his book out dated and that it should no longer be considered a mandatory reading. In using the N-word so excessively Twain shows how outdated his book is now, because in his time that word was very commonplace where as now a days it’s not so common.

            I do believe that Mark Twain started out writing this book with the intent of creating a satire that could hopefully change some people’s racist ignorant views. I don’t know how effective his writing was at the time that it was first published, but I do know that in today’s modern, changed, society his writing seems ignorant and offensive. His excessive use of the N-word makes the book almost unbearable to read and his Stereotypical slave portrayal of Jim and all other African Americans is so offensive that it should not be allowed in schools. Everyone should have the opportunity to read his book if they want to and they should be given the chance to make up their own minds about it, but nobody should be forced to read it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Works Cited

Twain, Mark. Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, A case study in critical 

Controversy. Second edition. Edited by Gerald Graff and James Phelam Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2004.

Lester, Julius. "Morality and Adventures of Huckleberry Finn." Adventures

of Huckleberry Finn, A case study in critical. Second edition. Edited by Gerald Graff and James Phelam. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s. Pg 365-366.

Kaplan, Justin. “Born to Trouble: One Hundred Years of Huckleberry Finn.”

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, A case study in critical. Second edition. Edited by Gerald Graff and James Phelam. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s. Pg 278.

Monday, May 4, 2009

Blog 10, final essay

Jack Coyston

Ms. Servais

English 1A

 

Huckleberry Finn: Racist or Satire?

            Fare warning there may be some offensive language used in this essay and my intent was not to offend anyone but to analyse the book Huckleberry Finn. I hope not to offend anyone with what is printed below.

 

            The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain has been called the greatest American novel ever written. Many people say that this book lead the way for other great authors and inspired many to become writers. However, there are also many critics who accuse the book of being racist ignorant garbage that should never see the light of day. It is my belief that Mark Twain did intend on writing a satire about how slavery was wrong and certain people’s ignorant view of African Americans were wrong, but I don’t know if he achieved his goal. Personally I was offended countless times while reading this book and although I can tell that Twain was trying to write a satire, I don’t think he succeeded. In order for something to be considered “satire” you have to be able to find humor in it, this was not the case in Huckleberry Finn; Twain’s portrayal of Jim is so over the top and offensive that it is not funny in anyway.

            Throughout the whole novel Jim is portrayed as a dumb, ignorant slave, who could never amount to anything. Twain portrays Jim in such a way that everything he does makes him seem simple and almost child like.  We are first introduced to Jim in the second chapter when Huck and Tom are sneaking out and Huck says, “We scrouched down and laid still. Miss Watson’s big nigger, named Jim, was setting in the kitchen door” (Twain 35). This description is so short, yet there is so much behind it. We as the reader are made to feel like Jim can be summed up in one word, “nigger.” It seems like there is nothing more about Jim that we need to know, other than that he’s Ms. Watson’s slave and he’s black. By describing Jim like this he falls into a stereotype that most people believed in at the time. That stereotype was, and sadly still is to some people today, that African American people should be slaves because they were dumber and weaker than white people and being a slave was all they were good for. Lester out it best when he wrote,

Jim does not exist with integrity of his own. He is a childlike person who, in attitude and character, is more like one of the boys in Tom Sawyer’s gang than a grown man with a wife and children, an important fact we do not learn until much later. But to Twain, Slavery was not an emotional reality to be explored extensively or with love. (365)

Just like Lester, I feel that Twain doesn’t really care about slavery, and is only characterizing Jim the way he does because he feels that’s how most readers will accept him, which at the time they did because he was what they considered your average slave. However, this is not how most people view African Americans today and so now it comes across as extremely racist. Twain continues the stereotype of “Niger Jim” throughout the book by how he makes him talk, the first thing that Jim says is, “Who dah?” (Twain 35). This is not how a respectable, intelligent member of society would talk, it is almost broken English. “Say-who is you? Whar is you? Dog my cats ef I didn’ hear sumf’n. Well I knows what I’s gwyne to do. I’s gwyne to set down here and listen tell I hears it again” (Twain 35). Jim talks like this throughout the whole book and it just makes him seem as if he’s unintelligent and almost child like.

            In this book Jim is not only portrayed as ignorant and dumb by how he talks, but also by the things that he does. The book is set when slavery was still present in the south and as a African American slave in America at this time one can only assume that Jim would be aware that if he travelled to a northern state he would be free and if he travelled to a southern one he would most likely be captured and made a slave again, yet he and Huck travel South even though it was very well known that African Americans were free in the north. Lester explains that,

The novel plays with black reality from the moment Jim runs away and does not immediately seek his freedom. It defies logic that Jim did not know Illinois was a free state. Yet Twain wants us not only to believe he didn’t, but also accept as credible that a runaway slave would drift south down the Mississippi River, the only route to freedom he knew being at Cairo, Illinois, where the Ohio River meets the Mississippi. If Jim knew that the Ohio met the Mississippi at Cairo, how could he not have known of the closer proximity of freedom to the east in Illinois or north Iowa? (366)

I agree with Lester, Twain makes it extremely hard to believe that anyone in Jim’s situation would make a mistake as big as heading further south and never trying to correct the mistake, and if we can’t believe that Jim is like a real person then we can’t believe any of the book is real. So Twains excessive use of the N-word throughout the book has no reference to the period that it is set in, because the story isn’t suppose to be true. So in essence by making Jim such an unbelievable character Twain loses all credibility and seems like he only uses the N-word how he does because that’s how he actually feels.